Children are more apt to pay attention and comprehend their lessons if they are not living in fear. Parental Support Parents may fear student safety in schools especially with the onset of widely publicized student bullying behavior or the presence of guns or drugs that may be brought into the school. Despite negative consequences, some might argue that increased use of exclusionary discipline by schools is acceptable if it leads to significant gains in safety and order in learning environments. What is more, Black and Hispanic students are much more likely than white students to experience exclusionary discipline. The act required states that get federal education money to pass zero-tolerance laws requiring the expulsion of any student who brought a weapon to school. Zero tolerance does not lend itself to offenses such as lack of school supplies, tardiness or having excessive absences. For instance, the newspaper St.
Skiba looked at other studies and found the same result. Those students who get expelled or suspended for things like touching pills are disciplined like that for a reason. Some school districts created zero-tolerance policies calling for suspension or expulsion for fighting, drugs, smoking, defiant behavior, tardiness and even truancy. This causes kids to ignore genuinely useful information about the relative harms of different drugs. A 2004 meta-analysis of 11 peer-reviewed studies concluded D. Kelling published their broken windows theory of crime.
In an important extra step, my analysis specifically assesses the impact of zero-tolerance laws pertaining to firearms, weapons, drug offenses, and assaults. Nowadays, it has been modified in context to include bullying and disruptive behavior in the classroom. Students are accountable for the actions and teachers are able to articulate clear expectations about disciplinary consequences and provide a chaos-free climate. Not only was she suspended from school, but she also faced felony charges. My neighbor was in and out of jail and was called down to the office often but yet he was never expelled.
The January 2014 release of a by the U. Some dislike the policy because it is claimed that it discourages report of behaviors by some that witness the breaking of rules. Parents of a student at Upper Elementary School contacted the school district after hearing about the plan. Zero Tolerance throughout High school 34% of L. An Oddly Shaped Breakfast Josh Welch was enjoying a strawberry pastry at school when he decided to get creative with his eating.
But at the end of 2015, Randi Weingarten wrote an editorial in American Educator saying those policies had been a failure. Nesa Sasser has served as teacher, school counselor, principal, and college professor. However, there is no data that supports African-American students or students with disabilities being more disruptive or more violent that would warrant such disciplinary actions. Sometimes behavior issues mask underlying mental health issues, like depression or anxiety. Clear Disciplinary Expectations; A zero tolerance policy sends a clear message, as it removes major offenders from school and allows administrators to act quickly with disciplinary consequences that are consistent, based on school policies.
You keep jumping ship and moving on to new ones, which would have been fine if a all of your best supported ones didn't come up in the last round where they can receive no response, and b weren't quoted from uncited materials. A Pennsylvania kindergartener tells her pals she's going to shoot them with a Hello Kitty toy that makes soap bubbles. Reasons for Zero Tolerance A primary motivation for enacting a zero tolerance policy is to minimize unwanted behaviors. Usually this expectation is met. Source: 9 Outrageous Zero Tolerance Policy Punishments Zero tolerance policies were put into place in an effort to reduce violence in schools.
Schools have little choice but to change. To our surprise, he was back in his seat after lunch, having snuck back into school because it was the safer option. Recent research has, however, begun to fill this gap. Results from a 2008 peer-reviewed study indicate that students who are taught by a police officer during the D. In the examples given in the beginning of the article, a better review of the context would probably not have led to the students being expelled from the school.
Alternatives to Zero Tolerance Policies There are many alternatives to zero tolerance policies that can help keep kids in school while also teaching them valuable life lessons. Student behavior problems may be about more than the behavior itself. The fact is, if we don't do everything in our power to deal, in a healthy way, with the problem now, it won't go away and we will have to deal with the problem, in other ways, within the community for years to come. She argues that it will likely never be possible to get away from suspension and expulsion entirely. Others believe that there are occasions of misuse or that the punishment enforced can be out of proportion to a given incident. Good job and good luck : Stefy PaigeZ Tied Agreed with before the debate: - - 0 points Agreed with after the debate: - - 0 points Who had better conduct: - - 1 point Had better spelling and grammar: - - 1 point Made more convincing arguments: - - 3 points Used the most reliable sources: - - 2 points Total points awarded: 4 0 Reasons for voting decision: Pro, defend your arguments.