Andrea yates not guilty. Yates Found Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity 2019-01-06

Andrea yates not guilty Rating: 4,1/10 1035 reviews

The Second Andrea Yates Verdict

andrea yates not guilty

The patients at Kerrville State Hospital are here not because they want to be but because the court sent them here for treatment. She was committed to a psychiatric facility for treatment. Like many patients here, Yates was found not guilty by reason of insanity, a defense raised in only about one percent of felony cases and successful in only about one-fourth of them. Texas is a very strong death penalty state, leading the country in numbers of executions. Six-months-old Mary Yates, killed by her mother along with her four older brothers.


Next

The Second Andrea Yates Verdict

andrea yates not guilty

Restrained herself even when the children were at their most upsetting. Nobody took this seriously enough. Her feeling that Mary, because she was a girl, was more disposable than the other children who could have been saved. Other than that it is their private business. The divorce was granted on March 17, 2005, after which Rusty began dating his second wife, Laura Arnold. That hardly makes sense if the motivations for one is selfish desires and the motivations for another are psychotic delusions. Although the prosecution had sought the , the jury refused that option.

Next

Andrea Yates

andrea yates not guilty

I'm no Fundamentalist, but I doubt they tend to kill their children. She had undergone inpatient psychiatric hospitalization just a few months before the children's deaths. Not only shouldn't she have been alone with the kids, she should have been in a hospital. She also told of vivid hallucinations, such as receiving messages from television and seeing the devil in her jail cell. If she ever gets better, and thus gets out, she will probably be an old woman. Recognized her psychiatrist would hospitalize her if she told him.

Next

Andrea Yates Found Not Guilty

andrea yates not guilty

Mac, By your definition, a heck of a lot of premeditated rapists would be off the hook. In addition, as one of her attorneys noted, the passage of time might have helped Yates. But they're not always in accord. The whole thing makes me sick. Anderson Cancer Center from 1986 until 1994.

Next

Jury: Yates insane, not guilty

andrea yates not guilty

That's why some, convicted of certain sex offenses and having done the time, can be locked up in an institution forever. Saeed's instructions to supervise her around the clock. Prior to her second trial, she told Dr. Mad animals are put down. This time, the jury deliberated almost four times longer than it did the first time. Imagine the terror of the children waiting for their turn to be murdered by their mother.

Next

Insanity Plea Successful In Andrea Yates Retrial

andrea yates not guilty

She drove her two children to the top of a mountain with the intention of pushing them off the edge. With more information available regarding the diagnosis of postpartum psychosis, Mrs. Very religious, to honestly wish to see another human burning in hell. Can you choose to become ill?? On the theory the the weak-of-mind need to be protected, you have a point. Broader inquiries are needed, particularly to determine where the mental healthcare system may have failed prior to those tragedies that do occur. Saeed's office, he testified, the doctor refused to try Haldol longer or return her to the hospital.


Next

Andrea Yates NOT GUILTY By Reason of Insanity

andrea yates not guilty

Mr Yates married Laura Arnold, a woman he met at a church in Clear Lake, during a private ceremony in 2006, two days before his ex-wife's murder re-trial He added: ''They spent a week showing pictures of our children's dead bodies in front of a jury, in front of her. The oral form of Haldol takes 4—6 days after discontinuation to reach a terminal plasma level of under 1. In 2008 his new wife gave birth to a son. In 2001, concealed it from friends to whom she had confided secrets on previous occasions. For the mentally ill, exercising one's will is based on severe distorions of reality, so I question your responsibility argument.

Next

Profile of Andrea Yates

andrea yates not guilty

Perhaps such a person would be a bigger risk than some of the sexual predators who society seems to think can never be let out on the streets even after their sentences are completed. There is no doubt about that. And I think some of her actions as described in the linked article show that she understood what she was doing was against the law. Let me just say that having grown up in an environment strongly shaded by one person's mental illness and her subsequent institutionalizations and having read and talked quite a bit about it, I think that the number of cases where personal responsibility for actions is completely abdicated is vanishingly small. But also, as in the first trial, the Texas statute favored Yates in a single, but important way even as it encouraged the jury to ignore her delusions. It just so happens that mental illnesses affect the brain.

Next

Yates Found Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity

andrea yates not guilty

The whole thing is a sham. Yates turned herself in immediately after the drowning deaths, Resnick said, because she thought her own death would fulfill a Biblical prophecy: If she were executed, Satan would be executed. This story was first published in 2006. Her attorneys said she suffered from severe postpartum psychosis and, in a delusional state, believed that Satan was inside her and that killing the youngsters would save them from hell. Did not tell anyone about homicidal urges for months. Rusty decided to purchase a 350-square-foot, renovated bus which became their permanent home.

Next

Andrea Yates Verdict: Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity

andrea yates not guilty

I suspect that the reason is that there's something more important and fundamental that relgious teachings that isn't formally recognized - maybe social mores. Criticize Rusty Yates all you want, but in our current system, if you have a family member with those problems, you are looking at living dangerously at some time or another. Said she possibly would have done it another day, meaning she knew she did not have to. Said she would probably not have done it if mother-in-law Dora had been there. I don't really have a problem with the practical outcome here so much as what I perceive to be overly confident statements about the inability of the mentally ill to choose and be accountable. I was raised by a mother who spoiled me like crazy. Yates said that she killed the children to spare them from Satan.

Next